The murder of a Burton toddler which caused outrage nationally, has been instrumental in securing changes to the way reviews into such tragic cases are conducted.
Ayeeshia-Jayne Smith, aged 21 months, was murdered by her mother when she was stamped on with such force it caused her heart to stop. It came after the youngster was suffered many other injuries.
The toddler and her mother Kathryn Smith where known to social services even before the youngster was born and during her short life professionals from different agencies, including social workers and health professionals, came into contact with the family on many ocassions.
The youngster was murdered by her mother Kathryn Smith, at their home in Britannia Drive, Stretton, in May 2014. An eight-week trial at Birmingham Crown Court in 2016 heard Smith stamped on her daughter so hard she suffered a cardiac arrest. She was sentenced to life, with a judge saying she must serve a minimum of 19 years.
A serious case review carried out after the trial, which looked at the involvement of agencies such as social services, concluded that the youngster was failed by the system.
The review was carried out the independent Derbyshire Safeguarding Children Board, which has said it is completely satisfied that its processes are entirely independent and properly conducted.
Tory MP Mr Griffiths stated at the time of the review that he was unhappy with the make-up of those on the board because he felt it was "too easy for a local safeguarding panel to select reviewers" know to it from neighbouring local authorities.
And during a Government consultation set up to establish new regulations for safeguarding children Mr Griffiths questioned the independence of the board selected to conduct the serious case review into agencies’ handling of Ayeeshia's case.
The Government has now decided that a national body should review such cases, with Mr Griffiths' comments among those considered when making its decision.
In his consultation submission Mr Griffiths said: “One of my major concerns about the serious case review into Ayeeshia’s death was a question over the independence of those who had been selected to undertaken the review.
"It seems to me that it is too easy for a local safeguarding panel to select reviewers who are known to the social services department, who are simply from the neighbouring local authority and who could potentially ‘go easy’ on those professionals involved. A national review panel would largely remove the possibility of those and allow a more independent and thorough review process to take place.”
The serious case review into Ayeeshia's case was launched was set up after it was found the child’s injuries before her death went unnoticed.
It looked at Derbyshire County Council’s social services department, and Burton’s Queen’s and Royal Derby Hospitals which saw Ayeeshia-Jayne as a patient several times.
During the trial, the jury heard Smith and her daughter had been well-known to Derbyshire County Council’s social services while living in Alexandra Road, Swadlincote, up until three months before her death.
She died a day after a multi-agency risk assessment meeting was called due to "a growing sense of unease" about her safety. Smith had been using cannabis throughout her pregnancy and this continued after Ayeeshia-Jayne’s birth. There were also reports of violence towards the youngster and child neglect.
Smith was found guilty of murder, while her ex-boyfriend was found guilty of causing or allowing the death of the youngster and was sentenced to 42 months, at the end of the trial in April 2016.
The trial heard there had been missed signs of child abuse throughout the toddler's short life. The serious case review later found that Smith needs ended up being put before her child’s by the agencies involved. The report also said social workers "missed danger signs" about Ayeeshia-Jayne’s safety, but also stated that the murder could not have been predicted.
Mr Griffiths’ latest comments were in response to the Department for Education’s recent consultation called Working Together to Safeguard Children. It has now published its findings and Government guidance to local councils and other organisations like schools, the police and health bodies on how children should be safeguarded, will be updated and circulated.
The new regulations will see the setting up of the Child Safeguarding Practice Review Panel, a national body which will oversee serious child safeguarding cases that raise issues of national importance.
In its conclusion, the report provided by the Government body said: “We note the points raised regarding the independence of reviewers. We believe that the guidance as drafted already makes clear the need to consider whether the reviewer has any conflicts of interest which could restrict their ability to identify improvements, but propose to add further clarification to the effect that reviewers should be impartial.”
Mr Griffiths also called for schools inspector Ofsted and the Department for Education to be given a greater oversight role in ensuring that recommendations from serious case reviews are properly implemented by local authorities. The Government’s consultation response agrees that Ofsted should have a role in looking at how recommendations from reports by the Child Safeguarding Practice Review Panel are being implemented locally.
He told the Burton Mail: “Scrutiny of local councils and social services departments is important to make sure recommendations are implemented in full and it is good news that Ofsted will play a part in ensuring this is the case.
“It is also vital that when a thorough review of such a serious case as Ayeeshia’s is completed that those reviewing the work of the organisations involved are completely independent to ensure they can carry out their role without fear or favour, and I had major concerns about those selected to conduct the review into little Ayeeshia-Jayne’s death.
“When something so dreadful happens as Ayeeshia-Jayne being killed by her own mother it is vital that social services and all of the other organisations involved with the family learn the lessons so that something like this can never happen again.”
A spokesman for the Derbyshire Safeguarding Children Board said of the Ayeeshia case: “The board is completely satisfied that its serious case reviews are entirely independent and properly conducted.
“The lead reviewer and the chair of the panel which oversaw this review are very highly respected safeguarding experts, with many years of experience between them of working for national child protection charities and in social care.
“Both are independent chairs of safeguarding boards in other parts of the UK, which underlines the level of confidence there is in their complete objectivity and impartiality.
“Each brought great knowledge and integrity to this review, scrutinising the actions of all professionals involved in this case in minute detail.
“The board discussed the appointment of both experts with the Department for Education and provided the department with detailed information about them, including CVs.
“We gave regular updates to the Department of Education on the review’s progress while it was being carried out and at no time was the independence of those involved called into question by the department, nor was the way in which the review was conducted or the robustness of its findings and recommendations.
“The board and its partners, as well as other agencies involved in this tragic case, have ensured that there are effective action plans in place in direct response to it, and, under the guidance of our independent chair, we will continue to hold agencies to account when and where appropriate.”
Kathryn Smith - a timeline
July 15, 2012
Ayeeshia is born to 19-year-old Kathryn Smith who was no longer in a relationship with Ricky Booth, the father.
Her midwife, Hilary Sayles, said Kathryn had been living in garage at her father's home. Mrs Sayles had concerns and that the living conditions were not of a standard and she seemed isolated. She was also concerned about Kathryn's ability to put the needs of her child before her own
By March 2012 Kathryn went to Swadlincote and was attending Burton and South Derbyshire College. The flat was supported housing for vulnerable young women. Kathryn was appointed a social worker Denise Leavesley. Before her birth, there was a child protection conference in June 2012 to assess potential risk to the child. The child protection plan was required due to possible risk of neglect. Both midwife and social worker had no concerns, and no concerns about weight.
August 2, 2012
Denise Leavesley said she found out Kathryn had waited for three days before going to walk in centre due to Ayeeshia's vomiting.
The walk-in centre told her to get to A&E but she never went as she said she had no way of getting there.
Mrs Leavesley tried to encourage her to go to Incredible Babies course but Kathryn was not enthusiastic. She also had concerns about the number of people visiting the flat which placed her daughter at risk of harm.
August 17, 2012
Samantha Thompson, a children's centre worker, was appointed to Kathryn and Ayeeshia.
She was hoping to try and help her get out, develop cooking skills.
When she discussed the support Ms Thompson got impression it was something she didn't want. Kathryn did not want professionals interfering in her life, which was just one example of Kathryn expressing her views in forthright manner when she decided she didn't wish to do something.
Ms Thompson repeatedly tried to contact her. She felt uncomfortable going to groups. She went to Stay and Play session which went well but she never went back.
health visitor, derby community health service, Sarah Shaw visited, noting the flat was clean and tidy, toys were available and there was appropriate interaction between mother and child. She encouraged her to go to cooking groups.
November 28, 2012
Ayeeshia was weighed at 5.25kg and mother and baby relationship was good.
December 10, 2012
There was a core group meeting at her flat to discuss developing cooking skills.
These sessions never happened.
December 18, 2012
Children's centre worker Ms Thompson made an unannounced visit during the late morning.
She met Kathryn's boyfriend, who was not Matthew Rigby. Kathryn was in her nightclothes. Ayeeshia was asleep and had been awake during the night.
Ms Thompson made efforts to meet without success and told Mrs Leavelesey she wasn't getting anywhere.
January 24, 2013
Mrs Shaw went to visit at 11am. There was no response at the door.
At 1.15pm she received text from Kathryn apologising saying she had no credit and had been in bed.
Mrs Shaw was worried she was in bed because she noted it as a regular occurrence.
Kathryn told Mrs Shaw that weaning wasn't going well.
February 20, 2013
Mrs Shaw made a home visit. She said Ayeeshia was thriving and there was a good relationship.
She was having two meals a day, half a jar at lunch, and pudding at 3pm.
February 26, 2013
Police made a domestic violence referral about Kathryn. She said her boyfriend had damaged the flat but refused to give a statement to the police. At another home visit by Mrs Shaw she gave Kathryn a copy of the report of a safeguarding meeting.
Kathryn said she wasn't bothered reading it and thought they wanted to take child from her. Her boyfriend was banned from entering the property and she was not happy that he had been banned.
February 27, 2013
Kathryn attended a conference. It was agreed to keep Ayeeshia on a safeguarding plan under the category of emotional abuse.
Three days earlier her boyfriend had smashed three doors.
March 5, 2013
Mrs Shaw found out about an out of hours referral to social services.
Her boyfriend had broken a mirror. Kathryn was invited to sign a written agreement that she had no more contact with her boyfriend.
Kathryn was denying that Ayeeshia was present during the mirror incident despite police saying she was.
She refused to sign the agreement saying she was not happy that he must not have contact with Ayeeshia.
March 6, 2013
Mrs Shaw made an emergency visit, and saw damage to the front door. She noted emotional warmth from the child.
Kathryn didn't want to sign the agreement, saying her boyfriend was good with Ayeeshia, that she loved him and was going to be around for the long term.
She said he had anger issues. Mrs Shaw was concerned. She said domestic violence could have an emotional impact on children but Kathryn failed to understand.
March 11, 2013
Mrs Leavesley attended. She noted Ayeeshia was smiling. Kathryn would not sign the agreement, saying if it was 'going to be like this you might as well take Ayeeshia now'.
She was tired of the child protection plan, and was certain the violence wouldn't happen again. Her boyfriend said it wasn't going to happen again and had been prescribed anti-depressants.
Kathryn said: "I am not going to be made to choose."
Mrs Leavelesy said he could not stay in the flat.
Over the next few months she accepted he had anger issues but they were no longer arguing and he had changed.
April 24, 2013
Mandy Palmer, a coordinator for Stonham Housing Association, saw safety glass smashed and door damage near the flat.
Kathryn didn't engage with her very well.
April 29, 2013
Mrs Shaw and Mrs Leaveley visited. Ayeeshia was asleep, and there was further damage to the front door.
Kathryn said her boyfriend had damaged the door by kicking and punching it. He had raised his fist and pressed his forehead against hers. She gathered up Ayeeshia and left.
She said he verbally abused her and kicked her in the stomach and later followed her around Swadlincote. She admitted that she had not reported this to the police.
She refused to leave her flat and became angry, started swearing and told them to take Ayeeshia away.
She later admitted that she had had an abortion.
April 30, 2013
Professionals decide it is no longer safe for her to be in flat. Mrs Leavesley makes an unannounced visit, but couldn't get her.
She texted her and received a reply from Kathryn saying: "We are staying here in our home, not going anywhere."
She asked the police to do safe and secure check. No sign of her boyfriend.
May 1, 2013
Mrs Leavesley had a meeting with Kathryn, told her of her concerns and risk of boyfriend and that she needed to prioritise Ayeeshia.
Mrs Leavelesy said she was an excellent mother but her choice of partner placing Ayeeshia at risk. Kathryn walked out of the meeting but the same afternoon she came back with friends who said her boyfriend was really nice.
An interim care order was made and social worker Steve Crean took over.
Kathryn later said she had ended relationship with her boyfriend, but had been out shopping with his family.
Steve Crean was concerned if she maintained relationship with the boyfriend's family she might come into contact with him.
May 16, 2013
A court hearing was held and an interim supervision order was made.
Ayeeshia and Kathryn were to live with Kathryn's mother in Milton Keynes, but Steve Crean discovered Kathryn had come back to Swadlincote and met up with her boyfriend, saying she was bored and had nothing to do and did not want to live there. She went back to the same flat.
Steve Crean said he would take legal advice and tried to see her.
May 29, 2013
Steve Crean saw her and Kathryn said she had not seen her boyfriend since she got back.
June 5, 2013
A court hearing was held. Kathryn said that on June 2 her boyfriend came to her flat, and she refused him entry, taking Ayeeshia from flat. Power to place with foster carer.
June - October, 2013
Ricky Booth saw Ayeeshia at a health care centre once a fortnight.
The foster carer noted Ayeeshia was weary of men but came to trust the foster carer's husband, she was fussy with food, and woke in the night but her feeding pattern improved and she started to gain weight.
August 2, 2013
Steve Crean has an assessment session and Kathryn was put on a domestic violence course.
Kathryn said her now ex-boyfriend had moved away and her eye were wide open and could see how abusive situations began in relationships, her priority was Ayeeshia.
August 7, 2013
A meeting was held and concluded if Ayeeshia was to come home it would be under a supervision protection order.
August 29, 2013
Ayeeshia was weighed. She was not seen naked by the health visitor and was not weighed again until eight months later.
September 4, 2013
An advocates meeting takes place. All parties agreed Kathryn has made progress.
September 9, 2013
Kathryn was allowed unsupervised visits.
September 18, 2013
Foster carer said Ayeeshia's routine had not been adhered to when she was with her mother.
October 2, 2013
A court hearing agreed Ayeeshia would return to Kathryn. Steve Crean collected her that day.
Naomi Pantall moved in to Alexandra Road and introduced her to Rigby.
October 24, 2013
Rigby and Smith are officially in a relationship.
Naomi said she saw some bruising to Ayeeshia's back and bottom, and fingertip marks on her back and leg.
She raised concerns with Kathryn and threatened to tell social services but never carried out threat. She said Kathryn was manipulative and didn't want to lose contact with Ayeeshia.
Lizzie Nugent, a housing association worker and Mandy Palmer went to visit Kathryn, and saw a young man wearing vest top they claim was Rigby. Rigby denies this. And there was a strong smell of cannabis.
Mrs Nugent said she heard a bang and then a child crying loudly. Kathryn opened the door and said Ayeeshia had fallen off the bed. The young man walked past them and into the flat saying Ayeeshia will be ok.
Mrs Nugent believed it was compliance and disguise to get rid of them.
Mrs Nugent said there was a smell of fresh and stale cannabis in the flat. Two women said this should be raised at a safeguarding alert. She said Ayeeshia's eyes were quite sunken, and that she would ring a social worker. She asked for safe and well check.
Then she rang again the following day and rang on third day.
Steve Crean seemed to be dismissive, she said.
November 8, 2013
Steve Crean said he her called back, but didn't input his notes on the computer until November 28.
November 21, 2013
Texts sent by Kathryn to Rigby complaining about Ricky Booth and that he didn't want Ayeeshia again.
November and December, 2013
Ricky Booth takes photos of Ayeeshia's injuries. He was bathing her when he noticed there was bruising.
He told Steve Crean about them who he said didn't seem too interested. Mr Crean made no record but did accept he had spoken to him.
January 2, 2014
Kathryn rang the police and said someone kicked her front doors.
January 3, 2014
Mrs Shaw made a home visit but didn't see them. She noted the damage to the door. Kathryn also texted to Rigby saying kicking her door is wrong.
January 4, 2014
5am: Kathryn made a 999 call, saying someone kicked her door. Ayeeshia was with Ricky Booth. Police said the front door had split in two.
January 7, 2014
Mrs Shaw saw Kathryn and Ayeeshia. Kathryn said girls living upstairs can caused damage to the door.
She said Rigby had kicked in the door as they were both locked out. Mrs Shaw noticed a cut to the lip and chin. Ricky Booth said the chin injury was due to a trip on the carpet.
She noticed a bald patch on Ayeeshia's head which Kathryn said she had seen when her daughter returned from her father. Later, a child protection medical was held at Royal Derby Hospital due to the hair loss. It was diagnosed as alopecia.
January 13, 2014
Metropolitan Housing told Kathryn that Rigby was banned from the flat and she was being evicted.
January 14, 2014
Sarah Slack, a children centre worker for Kathryn and Ayeeshia made several unsuccessful attempts to see her.
January 21, 2014
Mrs Slack made home visit to Swadlincote. Kathryn said she only saw Rigby in public. She was asked how she kept Ayeeshia safe in public.
Kathryn replied: "We don't argue in public."
February 3, 2014
Kathryn said she went out to Morrisons to buy nappies, wipes and dinner. She denied she was out to pick up cannabis but Naomi Pantall and Rigby said she had. She went out, believing he was going to have a shower.
When she came back she found ambulance outside. Rigby said Ayeeshia was in her cot, saying Kathryn was in a rush. She wanted a spliff and he went to bathroom to get ready to go out.
He said he didn't hear her go out but heard high pitched noise. He saw Ayeeshia was blue. Naomi Pantall heard Rigby's screams for help and phoned 999.
A paramedic was pushed by Rigby on the shoulder. Rigby said he didn't realise who he was, saying he was making attempts to save Ayeeshia's life and was in a heightened state of emotions.
Kathryn came over and had shopping bag.
At Burton's Queen's Hospital doctors diagnosed the incident as a febrile convulsion after there was a witness to the seizure and evidence of a sore throat.
However, doctors didn't recollect telling parents to strip her down if it happened again.
February 5, 2014
Steve Crean found out by chance of the incident and phoned the hospital.
February 7, 2014
Steve Crean made a supervision order meeting to the flat.
At 11.45am, Kathryn opened the door and Mr Crean noticed the Ayeeshia was a little clingy.
Kathryn said she was unhappy that Ricky Booth had been looking after Ayeeshia on his own.
His attitude he would probably have been preferable if Ricky Booth's mother was present because he was living with his mother.
February 13, 2014
Steve Crean spoke to Ricky Booth on the phone.
Mr Booth became angry and said Mrs Crean was only listening to Kathryn.
Crean wanted to undertake a parenting assessment for Ricky Booth, who then swore and hung up. The parenting assessment never took place.
February 17, 2014
Mr Crean visited unannounced. Kathryn said Ricky Booth had not seen Ayeeshia since she was discharged from hospital.
She stopped contact because Ayeeshia had been poorly.
February 21, 2014
They moved to Stretton. Tracey Roberts described hearing arguments which could happen at any time. She heard both voices shouting at each other. They swore.
If they disturbed her she would bang on the wall. It was possible to hear people talking but she couldn't easily make out words. Rigby said Kathryn would kick wall back if Ms Roberts banged on the wall.
February 25, 2014
Mr Crean visited. Ayeeshia looked well and Kathryn was very attentive. It said it was a welcoming home but seemed a bit sparse.
February 26, 2014
Kathryn phoned Mr Crean, saying she had split from Rigby as it wasn't working out. She was told she had to prioritise Ayeeshia and register with new GP and mother and toddler groups.
March 1, 2014
Mr Crean made another visit. She seemed surprise to see him. Rigby and her father were there.
March 11, 2014
Rigby sent text to unknown number (maybe Kathryn), saying: "I hate you."
Kathryn replied saying she never wanted him to leave. At 9.27pm, a 999 was call made to police. Kathryn pretended to be a neighbour.
She told the jury she didn't want to make it worse if Rigby knew she had called the police.
Police came over and spoke to both. The couple were watching a film in bed. It was logged as a no crime domestic incident.
March 29, 2014
Ayeeshia is seen at Burton's Queen's Hospital by Doctor Elizabeth Isaac, who could not remember who came with her to hospital. Rigby said he was there with Kathryn.
The notes say she had banged her lower lip on bath, causing a 3x2cm cut. In her notes she said there was no history of vomiting or loss of consciousness, no known medical illness, no history of allergy.
The doctor said she would have made a note if she was told the child had suffered a fit. Kathryn didn't remember being asked about the medical history. Rigby said he wasn't there. She was also weighed and it later revealed she had lost almost 1kg in six weeks.
April 1, 2014
Mr Crean found out about the lip incident. Kathryn said the relationship had not resumed.
She said Ayeeshia had banged her lip when Kathryn was in the bath. There was no mention of Rigby. Kathryn later said she had not witnessed the incident.
April 4, 2014
Kathryn sent text to Mr Crean, saying: "Matthew threatened to text you lies to make you take Ayeeshia, just a heads up."
At the same time, she called 999. Ayeeshia is heard calling out 'mummy'.
Kathryn tells the operator that Rigby is going to cut himself and blame it on her.
She was heard saying: "Put it down, Matt."
Kathryn later said she did not know if he had a weapon. She said she heard the kitchen knives box. Rigby said he had a mobile phone.
April 4, 2014
Kathryn called 999, asking police to remove her 'ex partner' from her home, saying: "He is getting me killed within a week."
Police came, Rigby was not there. Ayeeshia was there and seemed happy. She signed a restraining order, and the matter was referred to fire service after a threat to burn house down.
A secure letterbox was to be installed. During the argument Kathryn said Rigby dragged Ayeeshia's cot out into the garden, but did not burn it.
She left Ayeeshia in the house and ran after Rigby down the street. He later said he would blow up the house.
April 4, 2014
Mr Crean sent her a text asking how she was. Mr Crean sent her a text, and went round. Kathryn was at home with Ayeeshia and no one else. Ayeeshia looked well, flat was fine, and she was asked about the text.
Kathryn sent two texts to Rigby, saying she was in trouble with Mr Crean. She realised it was just an argument.
April 5, 2014
Kathryn rang the police to retract the statement. She said they were not going to see each other anymore, and she didn't believe his threats.
April 7, 2014
Burton watch manager at Burton fire station, Gary Phillips, fitted the letter box at her flat and did a fire safety check. He noticed Kathryn had a glazed expression and was slow in response. He smelt cannabis and saw a young child which is believed to be Ayeeshia.
Judge Andrews said: "He was the only witness who said Kathryn was with Ayeeshia under the influence of cannabis."
Kathryn said she wasn't under the influence. His concerns were sent to social services.
April 8, 2014
Mr Crean got email from the police about their attendance on April 4.
April 9, 2014
Mr Crean had a supervision discussion. Kathryn did not mention the domestic violence incident and that Ayeeshia was present.
Later attempted to give Kathryn an agreement to sign to keep Rigby away from her.
April 10, 2014
Mr Crean took it around the next morning. Rigby was arrested and interviewed and gave his side of the story about April 4 and denied he burnt a cot.
Mr Crean made unannounced visit to her home. He noticed the door was ajar and pushed it open. Kathryn was tackled about report from police about burning Ayeeshia's cot.
Kathryn said he burnt a Moses basket, and she wasn't going to sign an agreement to keep Rigby away from Ayeeshia as the previous care proceedings started because of her ex-boyfriend's agreement.
She said she had done everything that had been asked of her and Rigby was nothing like her ex-boyfriend. Mr Crean noticed that Ayeeshia didn't get upset or distressed while her mother was getting upset and angry.
April 10, 2014
Mr Crean received a text from Kathryn saying she wouldn't sign the agreement, saying she did an eight month course on domestic violence so she knew what it was.
April 10-17, 2014
Neighbour Tracey Roberts overheard a particular argument between the couple. She heard raised voices and a bit of screaming and swearing, both were shouting. She heard the voice of a child, saying 'stop mummy, stop daddy'.
The couple said Ayeeshia called Rigby 'Matt', not Daddy, but Rigby twice said she did call him daddy in his police interview.
April 14, 2014
Kathryn Humphries, health visitor, arrived at the flat at 11.30am and had no response, then knocked again. Kathryn opened the door in her nightwear. Ayeeshia was wearing a nappy. Humphries was unaware she was weighed in hospital.
April 16, 2014
Kathryn went to a hair loss follow-up. Doctors found her hair had stabilised and there was no other hair loss. There was no known cause of the alopecia.
April 17, 2014
Two community care workers went along to get Kathryn to take a drugs test, after call from the fire officer. There was no sign of Ayeeshia.
There was a smell of cannabis strongly in the lounge but Kathryn did not appear to be under the influence.
She was asked to take test and refused because she knew she would fail it.
April 21, 2014
Ricky Booth saw Ayeeshia alive for last time.
April 24, 2014
Rigby texted Kathryn saying he needed to get out of his bad moods.
Ayeeshia is seen by Helen Arnold at the clinic. There was a faint bruise on bridge of nose which Kathryn said was caused by fall off the potty.
She only managed to strip Ayeeshia to her vest because she was distressed. She weighed 9.14kg.
April 25, 2014
Mr Crean made an unannounced visit. Kathryn was alone. Mr Crean said she looked spaced out. He couldn't smell anything, but she wouldn't let him in.
She later text him saying she wanted a new social worker.
April 26, 2014
Rigby sent a text to Kathryn saying: "Don't bother texting me, don't be beating the dog it's not his fault."
Kathryn said she would never beat the dog.
April 30, 2014
A multi agency risk assessment meeting was held in Tamworth and convened because of the threat by Rigby to set fire to the house and the police were called.
It was decided that Mr Crean, with a domestic abuse prevention worker, would arrange a joint visit to the home.
Mr Crean said he was still unsure whether Kathryn and Rigby were in a relationship. She said they weren't.
Kathryn sent texts to her father to come over with money he owed her. Rigby and Kathryn took Ayeeshia to Rigby's grandparents in Nottingham.
The grandparents saw no marks or bruises when she was being changed.
However Judge Andrews said: "But you would see the child lying on her back."
Texts to her father that day continued where she said: "You know I haven't eaten for a week. You both (her father and mother) only have your precious James (Kathryn's brother) to care about, you don't have a daughter."
Kathryn later said she didn't mean any of it.
May 1, 2014
Kathryn texts her parents about the money. At 10.30am Ayeeshia got up and watched a film. They later went to the co-op, in Stretton. She sent a text to her father about blowing his door off.
Her father later gave her the money at her flat and left. Rigby said he took Ayeeshia in the house and put her on sofa. He said Kathryn was still angry and upset but didn't ask her anything.
Tracey Roberts left her flat, saw Kathryn pulling off the ivy and said hello, she didn't see Rigby.
Ms Roberts returned and saw the couple with a pile of ivy.
She said she heard shouting from flat, a man's voice, shouting went on for five minutes on and off.
Police knocked on the door. Mr Crean later sent a text saying he wanted to visit, but never received response.
Ambulance was called. Paramedics said she was cold to touch.
Detectives and child protection officers notified.
Arrived at hospital. Smith said to one paramedic she wanted to call for an ambulance sooner but Rigby told her not to. Kathryn later said this wasn't correct.
Twenty minutes after Ayeeshia died, police spoke to the couple.
May 1, 2014
Detectives speak to the couple in a room with Ayeeshia. Things became heated when they said bruising had been found on Ayeeshia's back. Kathryn said it had been caused by the potty.
The couple were described as hostile and Kathryn was aggressive.
Rigby questioned police powers to do a search.
Kathryn was angry and accused police of saying she had battered her child. Kathryn was pulling on the door, but police were blocking her.
She said if the officer didn't move she would hit her. The officer said she had never experienced such hostility.
The couple left hospital. Kathryn went to the police station. Rigby was concerned about his dog, which was then taken to kennels.
When told by police he will have to come for an interview the next day, he said: "You'll have to play Where's Wally to find me."
September 23, 2015
Kathryn Smith, 23, and her partner Matthew Rigby, 22, appear at Stafford Crown Court on September 23 where they both deny murdering Ayeeshia.
February 25, 2016
Murder trial begins at Birmingham Crown Court.
April 8, 2016
Kathryn Smith convicted of murdering her daughter.
April 11, 2016
Kathryn Smith sentenced to life with a minimum of 24 years for the murder of her daughter, Ayeeshia.
Matthew Rigby is sentenced to 42 months for causing or allowing the death of a child.
A serious case review is launched to consider the alleged failings by social services at Derbyshire County Council.
Kathryn Smith launches an appeal to overturn her conviction. Her defence argues that an interruption by the trial judge as she made her closing speech in Smith's defence caused "prejudice" in the minds of jurors.
The serious case review is halted until the appeal has concluded.
Appeal ruling is postponed as fresh new medical evidence emerges.
Kathryn Smith loses her appeal but sees her minimum sentence reduced from 24 to 19 years
September 5, 2017
A serious case review into the handling her AJ's case is published, highlighting missed opportunities